Nardi & Mata Perspective On Organizers Of World Press Cartoon Oeiras/Portugal 2025

"Allow me to explain my perspective on cartoonists, juries, and competition organizers.

1) Cartooning and editorial drawing, especially those without words, employs graphic rhetorical elements such as emphasis, paradox, and metaphor,

which can give rise to seemingly similar images. Without intentional copying or plagiarism. Consider the subject of "Trump": cartoons in which Trump

is associated with the idea of limiting (others') freedom and censorship are very common.

The cartoons that denounce his idea of authoritarianism through his gigantic and ridiculous signature are countless: his signature as a wall, as a

stitching, as a barrier, as barbed wire, etc.

Equally frequent (and inevitable) is the symbol of freedom (with the famous statue) associated with other elements (a red tie as a noose, a red tie as

a gag, various types of ties, an extinguished flame, a flame with Trump's yellow hair, etc.) to indicate its censorious and arbitrary nature.

If we are honest cartoonists, we should admit that at times throughout our careers, each with our own style, we have found ourselves realizing the

same graphic ideas that other colleagues had. Sometimes at the same time, when working with newspapers and on current affairs.

So I would ask all colleagues to be careful about crying scandal and plagiarism... because you risk accusing those who have worked in a way that

may not be original, but is honest.

2) I have participated in many competitions. I've won, but I've also been rejected. I've never accused anyone of not choosing my work. When you

enter a competition, you implicitly accept the rules and the jury's decision.

I've also served on many juries: the selection process is collective and demanding. It's often unpaid and often the source of unpleasant criticism.

The results of a jury's work are the fruit of discussion, voting, reflection, experience, and fairness. Only once have I resigned in disagreement with

the organizers because the jury's selection procedures didn't meet criteria of fairness and transparency.

Only once in over 20 years!

Therefore, I urge caution when accusing juries of lacking competence or honesty.

3) Finally, the organizers.

It's a profession so endangered that I don't understand this excessive fury against those who fight to give the world of cartoons the importance and

respect they deserve. Suggestions for improvement are welcome, as are constructive criticism! But for a week now, I've been witnessing unjustified

public and private attacks. The WPC has been trying for years to reward cartoonists who commit themselves to this profession. With the newspaper

crisis and the advent of AI, we've lost professions and space in newspapers (those that still exist). Many competitions no longer exist, and many

festivals struggle to find the financial support to continue their work.

The WPC returns after two years, amidst a thousand struggles and uncertainties, after having changed venues four times throughout its history, with

the sole purpose of defending the value of cartoons, caricatures, and gag cartoons.

The organizers have created a magnificent exhibition, showcasing the cartoonists' work, and have published an equally prestigious catalog. Now,

after all this effort, why is the WPC being attacked so disproportionately and undeservedly?

I repeat, the criticism and advice are appreciated, but the insults and accusations are incomprehensible.

Therefore, I will not join the chorus of my polemical colleagues.

I want to express my fullest and clear solidarity with the WPC, represented by Antonio, a friend and an unparalleled cartoonist, and with the 2025

Jury. I am confident that the next edition will be even better, and that useful suggestions will be taken into account to foster even better evaluation

and selection. I hope others will join me in supporting your meritorious work of defending and promoting this profession.

Thanks World Press Cartoon, thanks Antonio Antunes.

Marilena Nardi"

"They are saying a lot of nonsense and unfortunately some evil on the part of people who try to discredit the World Press Cartoon, people who,

because they think they haven't been selected and have their inherited Ego, are saying their shit about the organization. All the people we have had

the opportunity to share time with them and experience this festival of humor, we know the love and effort behind the organizers to ensure that the

best award that exists in this office continues to live.

With a jury, who is different every year, precisely to try to be as effective and clean as possible in his commission.

Against this injustice I want to convey my support in the name of all the people we feel affection for the World Prees Cartoon, that we are the

immense majority….and before the necessary words, our sincere ears only told my abuela.

Ivan Mata"

Add comment

JComments

Main Menu

Stats

Website Rank

+ +

Latest Headlines

52nd Edition International Graphic Humor Competition COMEDIANS IN MAROSTICA / Italy 2026

15:28.....2025/12/03

Winners Of 2nd International Cartoon Competition "ALG BEST TOONS 2025"/Algeria

18:53.....2025/12/02

Winners Of 23rd FreeCartoonsWeb International Cartoonent Festival / China 2024

16:37.....2025/12/02

Jury Members Of The 11th KalDer Bursa International Cartoon Contest /Turkey 2026

14:16.....2025/12/02

24th FreeCartoonsWeb International Cartoonent Festival / China 2025

14:08.....2025/12/02